I Can't Believe it's Not News
  • Home
  • Episode Guide
  • Satire
  • About
  • Support Us
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Episode Guide
  • Satire
  • About
  • Support Us
  • Contact

Episode Guide & Blog.  

Blinded by Science

3/31/2018

0 Comments

 
In this episode Beth and Kelly dive into SCIENCE! A few weeks ago an article about Astronaut Scott Kelly went viral that inspired us to look further into how fake science is put out as real news. In this case, it was merely a sensational headline that needed further examination to get to the truth, but many times science is used to generate clicks - whether they are based on fear (Scientists Confirm Chocolate Definitely Causes Cancer) or comfort (Scientists Confirm Chocolate Definitely Prevents Cancer). 
​
​Let's begin by looking at a TED Talk called Battling Bad Science by Ben Goldacre, a doctor and epidemiologist who writes a weekly column for The Guardian also called Bad Science. 
Picture
Dr. Goldacre gives a great breakdown of how we should look at scientific studies judiciously. Science has no easy answers, we must look behind the headlines that seem too good to be true, or too crazy to be true. We are meant to look at new data critically, question it and examine it. 

Some of these methods are pretty easy for the average fake news finder to use. The first question you should ask is: Is the person writing this a real authority in the field? You can look for publications by the doctor/scientist to see what else they've written - is it all from the same website? Are they published in a peer-reviewed journal, or is it all on naturalnews.com? Does the writer have a real degree in a relevant topic - unlike pseudo-scientists like Food Babe - the computer scientist turned nutrition 'expert'. 

Other methods of deduction are likewise easy to follow, but may take a small amount of time. If an article seems questionable, look for the source material. What does the real study say? And how was the study performed? Kelly and Beth discuss how studies need a control group to get a proper results. Also, that control group needs to be provided the best treatment currently available, not a placebo or no treatment at all. Even these methods can be rigged to get the best results for the new medication/treatment, etc. The control group can be given too low or too high a dose and these results are then incredibly suspect. 

Picture
​In one case Beth found that a Brietbart article on climate change looked at 58 different studies - and then presented them with entirely opposite results. Imagine how shocked both Beth and Kelly were to find that this Breitbart article was less than truthful with these results! The Snopes team reached out to some of the scientists behind those 58 studies and they couldn't believe it either. Who can we even trust anymore?!?

Picture
One of the most important measures for critical review of science articles is to check your source. Are they downplaying 'big pharma' while selling their own supplements? Are they shilling their own products without caring about the health and wellbeing of the person reading?

Kelly took these methods and used them in practice for this episode. She took a sensational headline from NaturalNews.com and looked into the study and found it was not conducted properly - in this case there was no control group at all - another big no-no. You don't have to look far to find the lie in this instance, and these handful of tips should help even the casual news reader identify fake science news.

Picture

Beth's Jam of the Week, Dirty Paws by Of Monsters and Men
​

Kelly's Jam of the Week, Bad Science by Ben Goldacre
​

Picture
Full of spleen, this is a hilarious, invigorating and informative journey through the world of Bad Science. When Dr Ben Goldacre saw someone on daytime TV dipping her feet in an 'Aqua Detox' footbath, releasing her toxins into the water, turning it brown, he thought he'd try the same at home. 'Like some kind of Johnny Ball cum Witchfinder General', using his girlfriend's Barbie doll, he gently passed an electrical current through the warm salt water. It turned brown. In his words: 'before my very eyes, the world's first Detox Barbie was sat, with her feet in a pool of brown sludge, purged of a weekend's immorality.' Dr Ben Goldacre is the author of the Bad Science column in the Guardian. His book is about all the 'bad science' we are constantly bombarded with in the media and in advertising. At a time when science is used to prove everything and nothing, everyone has their own 'bad science' moments from the useless pie-chart on the back of cereal packets to the use of the word 'visibly' in cosmetics ads.

Cited Sources:
Battling Bad Science - Ben Goldacre TED Talk   - TED Talks
SCOTT KELLY: NASA TWINS STUDY CONFIRMS ASTRONAUT'S DNA ACTUALLY CHANGED IN SPACE - Newsweek
​How Did Astronaut DNA Become 'Fake News'? - The Guardian
​Magnesium found to treat DEPRESSION better than antidepressant drugs: New science - Natural News
Role of magnesium supplementation in the treatment of depression: A randomized clinical trial  - PLOS One
Autism Parents Still Buying Into Bleach Cure From Self-Described Space Alien God - Forbes
DELINGPOLE: ‘Global Warming’ Is a Myth, Say 58 Scientific Papers in 2017  - Breitbart
Did 58 Scientific Papers Published in 2017 Say Global Warming is a Myth? - Snopes

​Join us bi-weekly for new episodes!  Follow us on Twitter and Facebook!  Don't forget to subscribe on your favorite podcast app!  We are on iTunes, Stitcher, Tunein, Google Play, You Tube, iHeart Radio, and Spotify!  
​If you are so inclined - help others find us by giving us a 5 star rating!

​
​And don't forget - Spread jam, not lies.
0 Comments
<<Previous

    Spread jam, not lies.

    Archives

    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017

    RSS Feed


    Teaser
    Episode 1
    ​Episode 2
    Episode 3
    ​Episode 4
    ​Episode 5
    Episode 6
    Episode 7
    ​Episode 8​
    ​Episode 9
    ​Episode 10
    ​Bonus Episode
    ​Episode 11
    ​Episode12
    ​Episode 13
    ​Episode 14
    Episode 15
    Episode 16
    ​Bonus 2
    Episode 17
    Episode 18
    Episode 19
    ​Episode 20
    ​Episode 21
    ​Episode 22 
    ​Episode 23 
    ​Episode 24
    ​Episode 25
    Episode 26
    ​Episode 27
    ​Episode 28
    ​Episode 29
    Episode 30
    ​
    Episode 31
    Episode 32
    Episode 33
    Episode 34
    Episode 35 
    ​Episode 36
    ​Episode 37
    Episode 38
    ​Episode 39
    ​Episode 40
    Episode 41
    ​Episode 42
    ​Episode 43
    ​Episode 44
    ​Episode 45
    Episode 46
    ​Episode 47
    ​Episode 48
    ​Episode 49
    ​Episode 50
    ​Episode 51
    Episode 52
    Episode 53
    Episode 54
    ​Episode 55
    ​Episode 56
    ​Episode 57
    Episode 58
    ​
    ​
    ​
Proudly powered by Weebly